Maika'i. I only do it in the summer though, cuz it can get really cold in winter, and I don't have a winter wetsuit. There have been some summer days where the waves are just perfect for me, while there have been others where it's too flat and others where it's too rough.
BTW did I tell you that I surfed on Maui? It was through the Goofy Foot Surf School in Lahaina.